In March, The Community Foundation Serving Richmond and Central Virginia gathered alumni of its Emerging Nonprofit Leaders Program (ENLP) and current members of its 10th class at the Black History Museum and Cultural Center of Virginia.
Jonathan Zur, President and CEO of Virginia Center for Inclusive Communities led the group through a robust discussion and brainstorming session on ways local organizations and leaders can take action to create a culture of inclusion in their nonprofit organizations and across the sector.
Diversity and Inclusion
By now, you’ve probably heard the buzzword “Diversity and Inclusion” or “D&I” for short. So, what is it and why is it important in our sector, particularly in the workplace? According to VCIC, diversity is the presence of difference generally related to one’s identity and might include ability status, age, race, ethnicity, gender, religion, sexual orientation, socio-economic status or many other factors that make a person unique. Inclusion is the accepting, respecting, and valuing of this diversity. Jonathan explained that, “it is very possible to have diversity without inclusion and if you’re not being intentionally inclusive, it’s very likely that you will end up being exclusive. Organizations need both diversity and inclusion to be successful.”
The Case for Creating Inclusiveness
Working to achieve diversity and inclusion in the workplace should be a fundamental part of fulfilling the mission of any nonprofit. It creates an environment of involvement and connection and allows for the richness of ideas, backgrounds and perspectives to be harnessed to create value for the organization, clients and the community. It has been proven to enhance creativity, produce better and more productive communications, result in faster problem solving and enhance programs and services to constituents.
D&I is an ongoing process for creating change and requires a commitment to education, collaboration and vigilance. Jonathan reiterated that the work itself can be uncomfortable, and the territory unfamiliar, but it can move organizations and communities towards health, harmony and justice. He suggested three steps:
Examine Your Lens
To begin moving towards active inclusion in the workplace, nonprofit leaders must first examine their own lens. Having a deeper understanding of your perspectives and perceptions will help you create a framework for approaching and addressing your own bias – whether that be conscious or unconscious. The Association for Talent Development suggests that as a leader you should develop the habit of deliberately becoming aware of any unconscious bias you may have regarding a person and the feelings that bias elicits, such as discomfort, uncertainty, or impatience. As your awareness grows, your unconscious biases weaken and eventually disappear, replaced by trust, respect, value, and acceptance of that person as a benefit to your organization.
“To reach others, we have to first know ourselves. And to contact the deeper truth of who we are, we must engage in some activity or practice that questions what we assume to be true about ourselves.” –Adapted from A.H. Almaas
Tip: You can take these Implicit Association Tests (IATs) to get a better understanding of your bias.
Ask and Encourage Tough Questions
Nonprofit leaders must ask and encourage tough questions to create deeper dialogue within their organization. Although this might seem difficult at first, it will allow you to connect and overcome challenges with others in a much more meaningful and productive way.
An important factor in committing to diversity is to recognize that you aren’t familiar with the culture, values, and practices of people whose backgrounds are different than yours. You need to be willing to learn and develop a clearer understanding of how their experiences affect their work styles, behavior, communications, and relationships. Asking and encouraging tough questions will help you gain insight into the current landscape of your organization regarding how diverse and inclusive it actually is. More importantly, it will allow you to build deeper relationships, empathy and understanding with those who are different than you.
Acknowledge Institutional Bias
Nonprofit leaders must acknowledge institutional bias, which are the practices, policies, structures and traditions that push some people up and others down based solely on identity. In the nonprofit sector, here are some examples of institutional bias:
- the pay gap between women and men is significant
- fewer than 45% of CEO positions are held by women, even though women make up 70% of the nonprofit workforce
- nationally 89% of CEOs and 80% of board members are white even though only 64% of the population is
- In a 2010 survey of nonprofit employees, more than a quarter of the respondents of color reported having left a job “due to lack of diversity and inclusiveness”
- Volunteer demographics often don’t reflect the population being served; one example shows the disparity between clients of Voices for Children and their volunteer base of mostly white, heterosexual, white women
- Studies show that the majority of foundations are governed by white individuals and the majority of benefactors to foundations are white individuals
- Nonprofits often require a formal degree for every job in our sector by default
Nonprofit leaders must recognize that certain bias exists within the sector and this may permeate into their own organization causing barriers towards inclusion and ultimately, equity and justice. Making sure to include individuals who may be facing these barriers in the conversation, may seem obvious, but is often overlooked.
Jonathan gave the group an example of how many organizations will post a job opening for a Bilingual- Spanish Staff Person and the day the position opens is the first time they are reaching out to the Spanish speaking population. Instead, Jonathan recommends, long before the position opens, or is even official, begin building relationships and having conversations with partners who will help connect you to that population ie The Hispanic Chamber of Commerce; you may even want to hold “interest interviews” to have a better understanding upfront what barriers may exist and interventions you can take to make your organization more attractive to those candidates.
So, what are some of the barriers that organizations, leaders and staff create in local nonprofit organizations that prevent inclusion (in both the workplace itself and with clients and the community) and what are actions steps that they can take to intervene and overcome these barriers, leading to a more inclusive nonprofit environment? Stay tuned for our upcoming blog post to learn more!